The Hidden Dangers of Variable-Priced Electricity Contracts for Pennsylvania Small Businesses
Pennsylvania is home to a thriving and diverse small business community, with over 1 million small businesses fueling the state’s economy. From bustling retail shops in Philadelphia to industrial operations in Pittsburgh, small business owners must carefully manage expenses to maintain profitability. One often-overlook factor that can significantly impact financial stability is electricity pricing.
With Pennsylvania’s deregulated energy market, small business owners have the power to choose their electricity suppliers. While this provides the opportunity for cost savings, it also introduces risk—especially for those who opt for variable-priced electricity contracts. While these contracts may offer short-term savings, they come with significant long-term risks, including uncertainty, price volatility, budgeting difficulties, and unexpected financial strain.
To illustrate these risks, let’s examine two business owners who made different electricity contract choices and see how it played out for them over time.
A Tale of Two Business Owners: Fixed vs. Variable Rates
In Lancaster, Pennsylvania, two small business owners—Tom and Mike—opened their respective shops on the same street. Tom, a meticulous planner, chose to lock in a fixed-rate electricity contract for three years. Mike, on the other hand, wanted to take advantage of the fluctuating energy market and opted for a variable-priced contract, believing it would save him money.
For the first year, Mike’s decision seemed like the smarter choice. His variable electricity rate was nearly 10% lower than Tom’s fixed rate, and he would often boast to Tom about how he was outsmarting the system. “Why pay extra when I can ride the market?” he would say.
But midway through the second year, disaster struck. A hurricane in the southern United States caused a major disruption in natural gas supplies, sending energy prices soaring. Pennsylvania, which heavily relies on natural gas for electricity, saw wholesale electricity prices triple overnight. For one scorching summer month, Mike’s variable rate skyrocketed, tripling his electricity costs.
While Tom’s electricity bill remained stable thanks to his fixed contract, Mike’s business couldn’t absorb the sudden spike. His energy bill, which typically averaged $2,000 per month, ballooned to $6,000 in a single month. Unable to cope with the unexpected financial hit, Mike was forced to temporarily shut down his shop, laying off employees and losing valuable customers.
By contrast, Tom, who had secured electricity price security with his fixed contract, continued business as usual. His predictable energy costs meant he could confidently plan his budget without the risk of catastrophic price swings.
Mike learned the hard way: what seemed like a great deal in the short term turned into a financial disaster in the long run.
Uncertainty and Budgeting Challenges for Pennsylvania Small Businesses
One of the biggest drawbacks of variable-priced electricity contracts is the complete lack of predictability. Small businesses in Pennsylvania often operate on tight margins, and being able to forecast expenses accurately is crucial for survival.
Variable pricing creates budgeting nightmares, as small business owners never know what their electricity costs will be from month to month. This uncertainty makes it difficult to plan payroll, allocate funds for expansion, or reinvest in business growth. Unexpected price hikes can throw off entire financial plans, forcing business owners to make tough decisions, such as cutting employee hours, delaying investments, or even raising prices for customers.
Extreme Price Volatility in Pennsylvania’s Energy Market
Pennsylvania’s electricity prices are directly tied to the natural gas market, as the state generates over 50% of its electricity from natural gas. This dependency creates high price volatility, as any disruption in natural gas supply—whether from hurricanes, global conflicts, or supply chain bottlenecks—can cause energy prices to surge overnight.
For instance, in Winter 2021, the Texas energy crisis led to a nationwide spike in natural gas prices. Pennsylvania businesses saw wholesale electricity prices increase by over 200%, leaving those on variable-rate contracts scrambling to cover the unexpected costs.
Small businesses, particularly those in energy-intensive industries such as manufacturing, retail, and hospitality, suffer the most when electricity prices become unstable. Without a fixed-rate contract, they are at the mercy of market-driven price swings, which can erode profits and force tough business decisions.
High-Risk and Unpredictable Electric Bills
Variable electricity pricing exposes small businesses to unpredictable and uncontrollable risks. Consider the following real-world challenges:
- Unpredictable Weather Events: Pennsylvania experiences harsh winters and hot summers, both of which drive up electricity demand and cause prices to spike unexpectedly.
- Supply Chain Disruptions: Any disruption in the supply chain for natural gas or coal—such as pipeline issues or geopolitical tensions—leads to higher energy costs.
- Market Speculation: Energy markets are influenced by traders and market speculators, meaning prices can shift based on factors completely unrelated to Pennsylvania’s local energy needs.
These risks make it impossible for small business owners to plan ahead, leaving them financially exposed. One unexpected price spike can wipe out months of profits, making it extremely difficult for businesses to recover.
Why Fixed-Rate Contracts Are the Smarter Choice for Pennsylvania Small Businesses
The only way to mitigate the risks of variable electricity pricing is by securing a fixed-rate contract. Fixed contracts offer the following key benefits:
- Price Stability: Locking in a fixed rate provides electricity price security, ensuring that businesses pay the same predictable rate each month.
- Risk Reduction: Fixed rates protect against sudden spikes in energy prices, shielding businesses from market volatility.
- Financial Planning Confidence: With a set electricity rate, business owners can accurately plan budgets, manage expenses, and allocate funds for growth.
Pennsylvania’s energy market will always be unpredictable, but businesses don’t have to gamble with their financial future. By choosing a fixed-rate contract, small business owners can gain peace of mind on their electric bill and focus on growing their businesses rather than worrying about energy costs.
Conclusion: Avoid Uncertainty—Choose Stability
Small business owners in Pennsylvania cannot afford to take risks with their electricity expenses. As seen in the story of Mike and Tom, short-term savings on a variable contract can lead to long-term financial ruin. The volatile nature of Pennsylvania’s energy market, combined with unexpected price spikes, makes fixed-rate electricity contracts the best option for small businesses looking for stability and peace of mind.
Instead of hoping for continued low rates, Pennsylvania business owners should take control of their energy costs today. Visit Electricrate.com to compare fixed-rate electricity plans and secure a contract that provides long-term price security.
Don’t leave your business vulnerable to the next price surge—lock in a low fixed electricity rate today.
Updated on
